WHAT DID SHE DO TO HER FACE???! Renee’s new look and the reactions behind it.

In Weber’s chapter on Makeover Nation, she stresses the critical role that the idealized conception of celebrity plays in the makeover’s construction of image and selfhood. The celebrity image is often one that is aspired to and deemed as the ultimate for upward mobility. Hollywood glamour becomes a product that can practically be bottled up given the right prescription – product, treatment, or surgery. This made me wonder about the celebrity makeover. Plastic surgery and procedures of celebs are constantly displayed on magazine covers, but the one that most recently made headlines was Renee Zellwegger. At a premiere last month, Renee was almost unrecognizable when she debuted her new look.

Screen Shot 2014-11-13 at 9.38.34 PM

Renee’s new look opened the floodgate of conversation filled with judgment and scrutiny. Every feature of her face became subject for discussion. Many of the responses to this celebrity makeover were assumptions that because Renee changed her look she “does not like herself” and is sending a message that “encourages an impossible standard of youthful beauty”. The outrage is pretty shocking considering over 11 million surgical and non-surgical cosmetic procedures were performed in the US alone last year. And according to the American Society for Aesthetic Plastic Surgery, the trend will only continue to rise as it has since the recession when people began “investing in themselves once again”. This idea of people “investing in themselves” is problematic and one that is often echoed on television. Weber explains that living life to its full potential becomes a sort of currency that justifies the pain and expense of beauty work.

Screen Shot 2014-11-13 at 10.50.12 PM

Weber uses Makeover Nation to describe, “one’s selfhood is intelligible through and on the body or it’s various symbolic stand-ins and functions as a critical element of both belonging to and participating in a democracy” (38). The makeover creates a celebrated selfhood that connotes a broader sense of value, visibility, and charisma. Weber also describes the After-body to have associations of financial success and upward mobility. But in the world of Hollywood aren’t these values standard? Does plastic surgery really mean that even a movie star like Renee Zelwegger is still reaching for this type of success? Is it possible to ever achieve such status? Or is that the cycle of makeover nation, to keep its citizens as active and constant participants of consumer culture.

Screen Shot 2014-11-13 at 9.39.24 PM

Many women connect to Renee for her portrayal of Bridget Jones, a character that was humanized and relateable for her clumsiness and imperfections. Some suggest that the outrage behind Zellweggers altering of appearance was due to fear. For those who may relate to Zelwegger or the characters that she has played may wonder, “what was wrong with her to begin with? is there something wrong with me?” The commentary ranged from snarky to supportive as many expressed a sense of empathy towards her decision and demonstrated solidarity. If anything, I think Renee’s alterations to her appearance clearly show that the pressure to attain upward mobility and this type of “currency” that exists in Makeover Nation is heavily present even in the world of Hollywood…maybe even more so. If celebrities are really setting the standards, what does that mean for us? Zellwegger’s transformation calls us to question our own role in makeover nation and how we choose to participate or work against it every day.


One thought on “WHAT DID SHE DO TO HER FACE???! Renee’s new look and the reactions behind it.

  1. Renee Zellweger’s “transformation” is especially interesting to me because of it’s visibility. I would be hard pressed to believe that anything less than a significant majority of American movie stars have had plastic surgery. The issue here is not that women, or specifically actresses, shouldn’t get plastic surgery. It is that this body work should be done in a way that is unnoticeable, seamless, and intelligible. Renee is a movie star, not a woman-of-the-week on Makeover Nation. This dichotomy is important to us, as consumers, because we see people on self-help shows as extreme manifestations of ourselves–A woman might get a cosmetic root canal (that could be a thing?) along with a breast augmentation, liposuction and rhinoplasty, but I am currently using Invisalign. We are both working towards, albeit at different paces, what Weber calls the “after-body”. This body holds the self-esteem necessary to obtain financial success and social mobility.

    Renee *should* represent the after-body. For most consumers, she has made it in society. She is still expected to invest in herself, but with the goal of maintaing, not transforming. Her surgery is uncomfortable for us to think about because it hints that the ideal self, and the ideal body, that we are supposed to be striving for is not an end-all, pass-go-and-become-successful thing. If Renee doesn’t have the after-body, then who does? Does anyone? Renee certainly has social mobility and financial success, so why am I striving for the after-body anyway?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s